Domain: Transparency | Level: MUST
| Type: Detective/Corrective
Statement of Requirement:
Node operators participating in protocol governance MUST document governance participation
policies including:
criteria for participating (or not) in governance of protocols where
the node is deployed,
criteria for evaluating proposals,
voting history (where disclosure doesn't create security risks),
and
conflicts of interest. Note that abstaining from or not casting a
vote where a Node Operator is eligible to do so is governance
participation covered by this requirement.
Provide transparency into Node Operator participation in governance
that can impact operations and could give rise to conflicts of
interest
Audit Procedures
Verify that
documentation accurately reflects governance participation across
all protocols, including claims of non-participation.
evaluation criteria are substantive (not "we evaluate on merits")
and address security, customer impact, alignment, feasibility, and
operator financial impact.
published history includes proposal IDs, vote, and rationale; if
withheld for security, verify per-instance justification; cross-check
on-chain for a sample.
disclosure identifies related entities, financial interests,
governance compensation, and personnel affiliations.
Key Evidence
Interviews with personnel, and other Protocol participants
Governance participation policy with evaluation criteria
Published voting history (website, blog, governance forums)
Conflict of interest disclosure
On-chain voting records matching published history
Success Criteria
Substantive evaluation criteria are published
voting history accurately matches on-chain records
Conflicts are disclosed;
withheld votes have per-instance security justification
documented participation with rationales is supported by
on-chain/forum verification
Failure Criteria
Any of these circumstances is likely to mean the Requirement is not
met.
Governance participant with no evaluation criteria or voting
history
Published voting history inaccurate vs. on-chain records
No conflict disclosure despite governance participation
A blanket security exemption is claimed to avoid publishing any
history
Common Failure Patterns
Generic criteria providing no meaningful transparency
Voting history is published for major votes but omits routine
governance actions