previous: Secure Node
Communication | Contents page | next: Restrict Control Plane
Access
Document Unsecured Channels
BSSC Node Operation - Audit Framework
Domain: Security and Access Control |
Level: MUST | Type: Detective /
Corrective
Statement of Requirement:
Node Operators MUST maintain
documentation of any instance where encryption is not used due to an
adverse impact on performance, including a risk assessment.
See it in the specification
Purpose
Ensure security is not compromised by unsecured communication
channels
Audit Procedures
Verify that documentation of unencrypted channels is up to date and
covers
each specific channel/service,
the rationale and quantified/qualified evidence supporting it,
a risk assessment identifying threats (e.g. eavesdropping, traffic
analysis, message corruption) and the likelihood of them being
realized,
compensating controls, and
appropriate authorization.
Key Evidence
Exception documentation per unencrypted channel (services,
performance justification with metrics, risk assessment, compensating
controls, approval, review date)
Security exception register or risk acceptance log
Performance benchmark data supporting justification
Network monitoring data showing compensating controls active
Network configuration
Success Criteria
Every instance of unencrypted cross-node communication is
documented
Each document includes performance-based justification, risk
assessment, and compensating controls
Documentation formally approved and subject to periodic review
No unencrypted channels exist that are not covered by exception
documentation
Failure Criteria
Any of these circumstances is likely to mean the Requirement is not
met.
Unencrypted communication channels exist without any
documentation
Documentation exists but does not include a risk assessment
Performance justification is absent or not credible (e.g. a generic
statement without measurement)
Significant discrepancies between documented exceptions and actual
network configuration
Common Failure Patterns
Exceptions are documented at initial deployment but new unencrypted
channels are added later without documentation;
risk assessments are perfunctory ("risk is low" with no
analysis);
performance justification is anecdotal without benchmark data;
compensating controls are listed but not implemented;
exception documentation is inadequately reviewed or renewed;
the operator documents only external-facing channels, ignoring
internal unencrypted communication.
Other Relevant Standards
A.5.1, A.8.24, A.5.36, A.8.20
CC3.1, CC3.2, CC5.2, CC6.7
4.2.1, 12.3.1
GV.RM-01, ID.RA-01, ID.RA-02, PR.DS-02
previous: Secure Node
Communication | Contents page | next: Restrict Control Plane
Access