Ensure transparency in reward payments and incentives
Audit Procedures
Inspect documented procedures and verify they require the logging of
all reward or incentive events received by the node operator.
Examine reward or incentive logs and trace recorded entries to
supporting blockchain records, transaction records, or other verifiable
evidence to confirm completeness and accuracy for amounts, timestamps,
and transaction references
Interview responsible personnel and confirm they are aware of the
documented procedures, understand their responsibilities for recording
reward or incentive events, and understand the process for reviewing and
updating the procedures as necessary.
Key Evidence
Reward event logs including transaction hashes and on-chain
references
Automated logging system configuration
Log completeness and reconciliation reports comparing logs to
on-chain data
Log storage and retention evidence (database records, backups)
Reward logging policy and log schema documentation
Success Criteria
Comprehensive reward/incentive event logs exist covering the full
audit period
Logs include verifiable on-chain references
Verified entries match on-chain data (amounts, timestamps,
recipients)
Completeness checking reveals no material gaps
Failure Criteria
Any of these circumstances is likely to mean the Requirement is not
met.
Any reward/incentive event occurs without being logged
Logs lack on-chain references, making them difficult or impossible
to verify
Cross-referencing reveals material discrepancies between logged and
on-chain records
Checking identifies on-chain events missing from the log
Logs cover only part of the audit period with unexplained gaps
Third party interviews identify payments that are not logged
Common Failure Patterns
Logs capture consensus layer rewards but omit execution layer
rewards (priority fees, MEV) or vice versa
Logging system outages create gaps with no process to backfill from
on-chain data
Logs are maintained in spreadsheets with no on-chain reference,
making them difficult or impossible to verify
Historical logs are deleted or overwritten due to inadequate
retention
MEV rewards from builder payments are logged at summary level but
individual events are not captured